High Definition Maps or HD Maps are the new generation maps that are powering machines and self-driving cars & autonomous cars. Read this article to understand everything about HD Maps. Full credit for the content from this article goes to and David Rumsey and Hanne Tidnam.
Table of Contents
- Why are HD Maps needed?
- What are HD Maps?
- How are HD Maps made?
- What is relevance if HD Maps in a Self driving car?
- How many cars do we need to create HD Maps?
- What are the challenges in creating HD Maps?
- How are HD Maps stored?
- What does the car really see in an HD Map?
- Is it important for HD Maps to be visually aesthetic?
- What are the legal issues of HD maps?
- What will be the unexpected consequences of getting HD Maps?
- Are maps exploding in the era of HD Maps?
Why are HD Maps needed?
Use of digital maps in navigation devices and mobiles has become passé, more so, because these maps are simple, primarily meant for humans, who can understand simple instructions as they navigate. In this era of autonomous vehicles, where machines and robots need to make decisions on roads, we need a new set of maps, purposefully built for robotic systems. Maps now need to be democratized beyond humans.
While robots have the capability to do some things more efficient than humans, humans are still much wiser. The real-time decision-making capability, when it comes to driving and navigation is one of those key areas, where humans still have the edge. For example, decisions humans really take for granted such as stopping the vehicle at the right place, watching for a traffic signal at the intersection, or to avoid a split in the last minute to avoid an obstacle on the road, become very hard for robots to make. So, as part of the decision-making process, mapping becomes a really critical component of helping the robots make the right decisions at the right time.
What are HD Maps?
The maps that are particularly built for self-driving purposes are usually called High Definition Maps or HD Maps for short. These maps specifically have extremely high precision at centimeter-level accuracy for precision. This is because the robots need very precise instructions on how to maneuver themselves, how to navigate themselves around the 3D space.
Why do we need so precise maps for driving down the road? In most cases, the tolerance for error might be high, but there might be cases such as driving on a road to the town hall that literally cliffs on one side, where there is no room for error. So, the maps need to be extremely precise and contain a lot of information, which humans may take for granted. Not only that the maps should contain where the lanes are, where the road boundaries are, we also want to know where the curbs are and how high the curbs are.
If it is 5 cm, we are approaching an era of a holy grail for mappers, as a 1:1 map if ever really made would be as big as the world itself. So, HD Mapping is really a 1:1 mapping. HD Maps are not just about scale, but also about comprehensiveness.
How are HD Maps made?
At a very high level, there is a hardware component as well as the software component. A hardware component is more visible because if we look at the picture of a self-driving car, you will quickly recognize it because it has a lot of sensors typically around its rooftop. And these sensors are really useful for map creation and map update purposes. There is a combination of sensors such as cameras, LiDAR, GPS, IMU, and radars. These sensors typically also help in providing redundancy to the self-driving cars, in case if any of the sensors fails.
When it comes for a self-driving car to precisely locate itself, the visual sensors such as cameras typically have limitations. This is where the LiDAR sensor plays a role in precisely measuring the depth or distance in a 3D space. However, both LiDAR and cameras are typically working together, running very fast, multiple times per second. If a car is typically driving at a speed of 70 miles/hr., at that speed the sensors are collecting a lot of data at a very high speed as well. In this scenario, the car is consuming and creating the maps at the same time.
The other part of this is the software. The software part is also really interesting, as the software powers the hardware to collect and record the data and this information must be made sharable.
What is the relevance of HD Maps in self-driving cars?
On a very high level, the software that runs the self-driving car consists of a software stack with four components, the first component is the perception system; you can think of it as eyes of humans. It’s trying to see what is on the road that the car is figuring out, for instance, do I see a human crossing the road or do I see a signal turning from red to green?
Another piece is called localization – and localization module tells the car where you are in the 3D space, and what’s actually around you. Example, the system says that you are 150 centimeters from the next stop line, here is a cross-walk of this width etc.
That’s when the Planning & Control module will kick-in and say, “Ok I am going to slow down, and then going to make a full stop at the next intersection.”
And then the fourth component is the mapping component, and you can imagine the mapping system to having tentacles into the above three components, just mentioned earlier. For instance, mapping and localization work, very tightly together, constantly comparing where you are on the map. It needs to know which object was supposed to be here and tell the difference. So, if I know there is supposed to be an intersection and a crosswalk, and I see a moving object crossing it, that’s probably a pedestrian.
How many cars do we need to create HD Maps?
A single car can’t really map the entire world. The question is not only how the maps are created, but how a map is maintained to reflect the changes on the road. For this, multiple cars would need to drive on the same road, and that data would be aggregated from multiple drives on multiple cars together. The more the number of cars you have on the road, the more data gets collected, and the higher will be the quality of the HD maps.
What are the challenges in creating HD Maps?
The cost incurred in creating the HD Maps is a big challenge, as we cannot send huge amounts of data over cellular networks. The way to address this challenge is to categorize the information to be shared in real-time vs the information that need not be shared in real time. So, things that really impact driving behavior needs to be shared and distributed with other cars that may be affected such as a known accident on the road, landslides during a rainy season, a road construction in progress etc.
How are HD Maps stored?
There is a lot of data being collected now and there will be more lot of data that will be collected in the future once we have more self-driving cars on the road. This is where the Cloud infrastructure comes into place, both for storage and computation purposes, and 99% of the computation is done over there.
However, each individual car will continue to have its own memory cells or storage that people call as edge computing. So, each car will carry its own storage and computing power, so that each car can make its own decisions independently if it is offline it should be fully functional. In the case, the maps are being continuously called by rest of the software stack such as the perception system, planning and control system many times per second. The change detection module needs to kick-in to check what looks different from the map the system already has, and identify if it is a really important change to be distributed in real-time or send it to the edge compute process, and activate the active data collection process and share that data within the cloud.
What does the car really see in an HD Map?
How we want to visualize depends on how we ultimately want to consume it. Unlike humans who need to see to visualize the data, the robots need to consume the data, which they do through APIs and so on.
So, why is there a need to have a visual representation at all then? The answer is; those are for humans! As part of the map creation and update process, we need to have human operators to check the computer output. To see, the ambiguities in the real world, for example, a complex intersection – that makes it even impossible for humans some time to interpret the traffic rules. So, we have these visualization tools that really help in the map creation and maintenance process.
Is it important for HD Maps to be visually aesthetic?
When it comes to creation and maintenance of HD Maps, functionality triumphs over beauty aspect, as it is important to ensure the quality of the map is really high. Otherwise, the human operators won’t be able to work effectively. So, productivity and efficiency are above all than the design.
But when these maps are displayed for other purposes for simulation and virtual reality, then depending on the use case, the design choices of the maps are made.
What are the legal issues of HD maps?
Maps have always carried this aspect of law of the land, issues with geographic names, legal issues such as where someone is allowed, where someone is not, where the maps can be shown, where they cannot be.
Even though digital maps are widely available today, there are countries around the world that heavily regulate their geospatial data, and even forbid exporting geospatial data. This problem is inherent though from normal navigation maps.
When it comes to HD Maps, this is going to be a huge challenge, as the government regulations are not clear. There is going to be all sorts of sensitivities, as the cars have very high-resolution LiDAR and then the cameras are constantly scanning the streets and seeing into areas like private driveways etc. So, being able to protect people’s privacy and also follow government regulations from a security point of view, and ensure that data is sufficiently encrypted so that it won’t accidentally leak out are some key areas to be addressed.
In some countries, the governments are getting active now where they are trying to both protect privacy aspects and also advance the self-driving technology. It will be few years before the dust settles and we see an action coming from technology and policy standpoint.
Aspects related to who owns the data are also to be addressed – is the car owner who owns the data or the car maker or should the government own the data? These aspects were always there with maps and will be getting more powerful with the advent of dynamic maps.
How can we say that the maps are exploding in the era of HD Maps?
All these years, we tend to have simplified the maps to the very extent possible. To the geographic boundaries, to the oceans to the roads. But now, we are moving in a different direction where the maps are simply exploding and scale and dimension and maps have become reality.
And the real lag between consuming and creating a map is reducing, cars will have the capability to share information, which was not possible in case of mapping ever. Mapping will now become more of an organic process, with a continuous collection capability in place.
What will be the unexpected consequences of getting HD Maps?
When we are creating HD Maps of a city, we are creating the digital infrastructure of a city’s road network. And every city authority tries to do the same, as most are now having the GIS data for the city – which are created by sending out the surveyors. Public works departments often do the same. These are mostly static, very labor intensive, very costly to do and these kinds of surveys can’t be repeated all the time.
On the other hand, when we have cars with the right sensors running on the road, they are constantly updating the road. So, the process where a central authority from the government maintains this digital infrastructure can suddenly be solved with people with cars or just with cars. And this information is really useful just beyond self-driving.
As everybody becomes a mapper, everybody contributes when they are driving, and thus people become an integral part of this knowledge creation, and it becomes part of empowering people.
Listen to this podcast on HD Maps and Autonomous Vehicles